Under the Hood #1: From Dealership Technician to Automotive Engineer

Welcome to the first issue of Under the Hood.

Twice a month, this newsletter will bring you a conversation with someone working in the automotive industry right now: how they got their start, the biggest challenges they’ve faced, the most fun projects they’ve worked on, and which classes actually turned out to be useful. No recruiting-brochure polish, just the real version.

For this first issue, I figured I should go first. I started out as a technician at a dealership, ran the machine shop at Delaware Technical Community College, and went on to work as an automotive engineer at GM and Ford. Here are the questions students ask me most, answered as honestly as I can.

Getting started

When did you first get interested in cars and engineering?

I first got interested in cars in high school. I attended Hodgson Vo-Tech High School, a technical high school where automotive technology was my main career area. By my sophomore year, I realized I really enjoyed working on cars, but I didn’t want to only fix them. I loved how cars blend mechanical engineering with artistic design. I was curious to learn more about how they were designed, and that curiosity is what led me to pursue engineering.

You started as a technician at a dealership. What did working on cars teach you that engineering school didn’t?

Working at a dealership gave me firsthand experience with how a dealership interacts with customers: their complaints, their frustrations, and the verbatims they write up when something isn’t right. I got to see how dealer networks handle those complaints, how shops actually operate, and how technicians take a customer’s description of a problem and work through the troubleshooting process.

Anthony Bernal working as an automotive technician at Martin Honda dealership in Newark, Delaware
Working as an automotive technician at Martin Honda in Newark, Delaware, in May 2010

That experience paid off later. When I was working in noise and vibration at GM, I used what I’d learned at the dealership to develop training material for technicians on how to handle abnormal noise concerns. If a vehicle has a buzz, squeak or rattle, what does that usually mean? What are the likely root causes? How do you diagnose it and correctly identify the root cause, so you’re not replacing the wrong parts and seeing the same car come back again and again?

How did you break into the automotive industry?

Through SHPE, the Society of Hispanic Professional Engineers. A friend who knew I wanted to get into the automotive industry recommended that I join, and if it wasn’t for SHPE, I wouldn’t be where I am today.

Engineering students competing in the Nissan design competition at the 2017 SHPE National Convention in Kansas City
Competing in the Nissan design competition at the 2017 SHPE National Convention in Kansas City

In 2017, I didn’t have enough money to attend the SHPE national convention. But that year there was a Nissan design competition, and if you were selected to compete, they paid for your registration. That’s how I was able to go. My team took second place, and that gave me the chance to connect with people from General Motors. GM gave me an interview, flew me from Philadelphia to Detroit to visit the Milford Proving Ground and do a formal interview, and offered me a job shortly after. Working in the automotive industry had been a dream of mine, and it was SHPE that opened the door.

Anthony Bernal's team, second-place finishers in the Nissan design competition at the 2017 SHPE National Convention
Our team took second place in the Nissan design competition at SHPE 2017

That’s one of the reasons I’m such an advocate for engineering societies. The small college I went to didn’t have a SHPE chapter, and it didn’t matter. I was still able to attend the national convention, use the career fair and take advantage of everything SHPE offers.

Working in the industry

What’s the difference between working at GM and working at Ford?

For me, the biggest difference comes down to culture. Unfortunately, GM has gone through a series of layoffs pretty much since I joined the company, and that has taken a toll on the overall company culture. I very much enjoyed my time at General Motors, where I made many great friends and met super talented and intelligent engineers. However, the company culture at Ford is better than at GM.

The newly revealed mid-engine C8 Chevrolet Corvette in the GM Design studio lobby, July 2019
With the newly revealed C8 Corvette in the GM Design studio lobby, July 2019

The other big difference is the leadership structure and the way teams work with each other. GM tends to have a more top-down structure, a bit like the military: there’s one source of truth, that person makes the decision, and the rest of the teams follow their lead. Ford’s vehicle development process works more like a system of checks and balances, a bit like Congress. Decision-making power is divided among several people, and you need to get them to agree before a decision gets made, which makes the process more dynamic.

The 2005 Ford Shelby GR-1 concept car on display inside Ford World Headquarters in Dearborn, Michigan
The 2005 Ford Shelby GR-1 concept inside Ford’s new World Headquarters in Dearborn, Michigan

Both systems have their advantages and disadvantages, and it’s interesting to see how each one shapes the vehicles the two companies end up building.

What’s the most fun project you’ve worked on?

So far in my career, it has to be my time as a mass performance engineer at General Motors. I had the opportunity to develop a moments of inertia tool that could estimate a vehicle’s moments of inertia very early in the program, for the noise and vibration and vehicle dynamics teams to use. That project quickly grew into mass compounding: developing a way to quantify and really understand how mass flows throughout the vehicle.

It was a fun time because I got to apply most of what I learned in college: vibrations, dynamics, statics, mechanics of materials, Newtonian physics, conservation of energy and second-order differential equations. I had to go back to basics and apply first-principles physics to build the tool. It was eye-opening to take all the equations and concepts you see in school and put them together into one giant model that showed us how mass compounds and flows throughout the vehicle.

Through that work, I became one of the most knowledgeable people at GM on the subject of mass compounding, and that was really rewarding for me in my career.

Advice for students

Technician or engineer: what’s the real difference?

My teacher back in high school told me that a mechanic turns the bolts, but a technician knows why they’re turning the bolts. I think that captures the difference between just anybody turning a wrench to fix a vehicle and someone who actually understands how vehicles work.

To take it to the next level, the difference between a good technician and an engineer is how far back you go. To address the symptom the customer is experiencing, a technician identifies the component that has gone bad, replaces it with a new one and puts the vehicle back together. That’s as far as the job goes. An engineer asks why that component failed and traces it back to the real root cause.

Here’s a made-up example. Say a sensor in a door panel goes bad. A technician finds the bad part, replaces it, and the door is fully functional again. Great. An engineer has to ask what caused that sensor to fail. Maybe it was water damage. So how did water get into the door? Maybe a grommet has a bad seal. Then what’s causing the grommets to seal badly? Is there a quality spill with the grommets at the supplier, or is it a process problem at the manufacturing plant, where the grommet isn’t being seated correctly? It’s the difference between the symptom, which is what the customer sees, and the root cause, which is what actually led to it. That extra depth of understanding and problem solving is what really sets an engineer apart from a technician.

That said, there’s no shortage of car enthusiasts working as automotive engineers. Many of my coworkers are into racing, restoring cars or off-roading, and a lot of engineers still work on cars on the side.

I’m a high school student who wants to become an automotive engineer, but I don’t live near Detroit or any other automotive hub. What should I do?

First, let’s set expectations. Getting hired as an engineer at a major automaker is not easy. Several thousand students apply to each company every year, and a couple hundred, if that, get in. It’s very difficult to get into the automotive industry straight out of college, but it is possible.

If you live far from an automotive hub like Detroit, I’d recommend getting a job at your local dealership, whether it’s in sales, service or the parts department. That field experience gives you something to talk about in future interviews, and it’s something most engineers don’t have. Plenty of them work on their own cars as a hobby, but they’ve never actually spent time at a dealership. And there are dealerships all over the country, so there’s bound to be one close to you.

I’d also highly encourage you to join engineering societies like SHPE, SWE and NSBE. These organizations hold annual conferences that recruiters from the major automakers attend. Just like it was for me, that might be the only way you can get in front of major automotive recruiters and have a chance to shoot your shot.

If you’re still in high school, start by researching which colleges and universities the company you’d like to work for hires from directly. For automotive engineering, for instance, just about every automaker recruits from the University of Michigan. These large companies go straight to that school’s career fair, which gives its students another chance to get in front of recruiters. Knowing which universities your target companies recruit from is a real advantage when you’re choosing where to go to college.

Your turn

Have a question you’d like an engineer to answer, or someone you’d like to see featured? Just reply to this email. If you know a student who’d enjoy this, please forward it along. They can sign up for free at engineeringcheatsheet.com.

See you in two weeks,
Anthony Bernal
Engineering Cheat Sheet


Let’s connect on LinkedIn

Whether you’re a student figuring out your next step or already working in the industry, I’d love to connect. Send me a request on LinkedIn and add a quick note that you read Under the Hood. I’m happy to answer questions, share advice and point you toward people in the industry worth knowing.

Connect with me on LinkedIn: linkedin.com/in/j-anthony-bernal-10

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

We are sorry that this post was not useful for you!

Let us improve this post!

Tell us how we can improve this post?


Discover more from Engineering Cheat Sheet

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *